02/15/09

Disappointed on Valentine's Day, Never coming back again

by MPFL

We had pretty high expectations judging from comments on citysearch and yelp. Suffice it to say, my wife and I were tremendously letdown. For $260 dollars, on Valentine's day, with a prix fixe menu, you'd at least expect something cooked properly, if not something to remember (well, we remembered, but not because of the good food).

1. For appetizers we had lobster with fried oyster with a lobster broth. The lobster was cooked well, not overcooked, but tasted bland. The broth had a hint of beef broth, but was all in all edible.

2. We shared the quail which was also cooked well. The other appetizer, crab ravioli, tasted like something you'd find at Trader Joe's. The pasta was undercooked and the crab filling didn't have any flavor. The citrus broth that came with it didn't add anything to dish.

3. For entrees: The beef tenderloin was cooked well, a little rare for my wife's taste. Of note is that the waiter didn't ask how we wanted it prepared. It didn't have much flavor, other than tasted like it was rubbed down with salt. There wasn't much sauce, and what was there was literally dried to the plate to a point where I couldn't even scratch it with my fork. Luckily, the steak was so rare, it was still soft.

For the cod, my wife tasted it and told me that it was blend. I didn't think it could be that bad until I tasted it. The fish was overcooked, the skin was not torched (it was called "brulee"), so it's not crispy, just a limp piece of fish skin there. The fish was not seasoned at all. The "foie gras" mousse didn't taste like anything, definitely didn't taste like foie gras. It also just looked like raw liver. The "rice croquette" tasted like some nuts, didn't know what it was there for 'coz it didn't add to the dish at all.

The best dish of the evening was the dessert. But even that wasn't saying much of this place. We definitely will NOT come back to Luce. We were greatly disappointed, and wish we could have our money back.

• Pros: can't think of one
• Cons: Overpriced, food not up to par, slow service

11/18/08

Beautiful, artistic, harmonious, delicious!

by yramssay

We had the tasting menu here on last Saturday evening. I have to say it was one of the best tasting meals I've had this year.

The fourth course was absolutely perfectly executed. It was bone marrow with celery leaves and Italian parsley, and foie gras with amazing sauce with vanilla. The portion of the marrow was perfect, and oh the combination of the ooze and the crisp slight saltiness from the herbs! This plate was really "the" one for my high cholesterol but we only live once. I'm glad that I experienced this plate before the high cholesterol may take my life.

The Napa merlot we had from the pork to the cheese course was fantastic. The way this wine tasted with presented California soft goat cheese was as if somebody just put 2 missing puzzle pieces together. Because it was so perfectly paired I wanted to test it out with the Rioja from earlier. Ugh. It just proved that the sommelier here really knew how to paint a beautiful picture of flavors.

I thought the way the plates were executed was better than at Providence, now 2 star Michelin LA restaurant. I wouldn't be surprised if Luce scored one star next year. Why not two, you ask? The mixology from the bar was nearly not at the level of the wine or the food. The cocktail was sweet, sugary and no flavor, and especially had no place next to the carefully executed food. Also, although our server was attentive, knowledgeable, and polished, the demeanor of other front of the house staff was not polished as you would expect from a 2 star Michelin house. In this aspect, Providence was magical.

I don't doubt the already celebrated Chef Crenn's first Michelin star next year. At Range in Mission of San Francisco, the server didn't know what the "tasting menu" meant, and they have managed to keep a star from 08 and 09 after all

• Pros: Food and wine paring
• Cons: Bar not up to par

11/03/08

Good experience, but not great...

by rrao34

This restaurant is good, not great. The choices on the menu are exotic and unusual, but not Ivery talian (nor enthralling). It felt like they were trying very hard to be overly upscale but the food missed the mark (especially the dessert). SF dining is held to a different standard and I thought, for the price/value, it was not there for me. If I wasn't told this is an Italian restaurant, I'm not sure I would have known. The stylish decor does make for great dining ambience thouugh.